Unequal access: Roma and the health sector
15 February 2013 - Dotcho Mihailov
Various studies have shown that Roma suffer from poorer health than the general populations in the Central and Southeast European countries in which they are most numerous.
This brief analyzes health data from the 2011 UNDP/World Bank/EC regional Roma survey, which compared the living standards of Roma and non-Roma communities living in close proximity in 12 Central and East European countries. >> More on our Roma work
The survey findings demonstrate reduced access to health insurance, lower child vaccination rates, difficult physical access to medical services, and affordability concerns.
They also indicate that Roma are more likely to only recognize health problems as such once they reach acute forms later in life, resulting in a higher incidence of disabilities, long-standing illnesses, and greater numbers of in-patient visits.
Combinations of socio-economic deprivation, resulting from Roma isolation from the social mainstream (particularly the educational system and formal labour markets) and unhealthy lifestyles, are usually blamed for these outcomes.
Access to health services. Compared to non-Roma living in close proximity, health care coverage and disparities in equity of access remain an issue for Roma and other ethnic minorities in these countries. Roma continue to have inferior access to health insurance, and to specialized health services, aggravated by low awareness of health issues.
Abbreviations: AL (Albania), BA (Bosnia and Herzegovina), BG (Bulgaria), H (Hungary), HR (Republic of Croatia), CZ (Czech Republic), MD (Moldova), ME (Montenegro), MK (the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia), RO (Romania), RS (Republic of Serbia), SK (Slovakia). See EUROSTAT.)
Perceptions of health status. Although Roma generally have positive perceptions of their health, they report larger numbers of inpatient and emergency medical visits, and are more likely to suffer from disabilities and addictions. This can be explained by Roma households’ low access to health services.
“During the past 12 months, how many separate overnight stays have you made at a health facility?”
Maternal and child health. The frequency of unassisted births outside of hospitals — for both Roma and non-Roma living in close proximity — were particularly high in Serbia, fYR Macedonia, and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The survey data also highlight significant differences in child vaccination rates, a key indicator of health vulnerability, particularly for Roma respondents.
Drivers of Roma health vulnerability. Socio-economic determinants, especially official employment and education status, have a large impact on Roma health conditions.
Affordability barriers to health services have declined in most of the countries surveyed, for both Roma and non-Roma respondents. Since 2008, household incomes and spending in many of these countries have stagnated, and jobless rates have risen. This raises questions about the future ability of favourable socio-economic trends to generate continued improvements in Roma health conditions.
Conclusions and recommendations
The 2011 survey results show that, despite some improvements since 2004, the principle of universal access to reproductive and child health – as articulated in the Millennium Development Goals –continues to be honoured in the breach. Differences between countries are larger than differences between Roma and non-Roma living in close proximity. Comparisons indicate that the shifts in health outcomes that have occurred are common for both Roma and non-Roma samples.
Support for Roma should focus on making official health, education and employment systems more inclusive. However, some issues, such as health education, child vaccinations and reproductive health need to be addressed urgently.
The introduction of “health mediators” and other community-based approaches would strengthen the interface between formal health institutions and Roma communities, rather than creating parallel health structures and services.
Albania, Bulgaria, Moldova and Romania face important challenges in improving access to health in general – not just for Roma.
Three-year-old Larysa and four-year-old Yuliya are smiling shyly as the TV cameras zoom in. They are cutting blue ribbons during the inauguration ceremony of the IDP center in a sleepy town of Balaklia in Kharkiv region. Massive shelling that razed their home to the ground forced them to stay in a cmore
“When you are the sole woman representative in a community, and you need your voice to be heard and considered, you had better be knowledgeable and very prepared”, says Narine. Narine Geghamyan was elected as a local council (Avagani) member in the Kamaris community of Armenia just over two years agmore
Hundreds of residents of Zadar now regularly flock to the market each Saturday morning to buy fresh fruit, vegetables and other produce directly from local farmers who previously struggled to find an outlet for their goods. The new market has provided a much-needed boost to the incomes of local farmmore